First Masterlist

Summary: Sam finds out that Benny got to his big brother first in the worst possible way.

Rating: 18+

Pairing(s): dark!Benny x Sam || Sam x Dean || Mentions of Dean x dark!Benny

Tags: drunk!Sam, hints of drugging, non-con, m/m, major angst, first time, anal virginity, incest (Brother/brother), blowjob, anal fingering, lube, orgasms, bottom!Sam, top!Benny, top!Dean, mentions of bottom!Dean and top!Sam

A/Ns: This is for Andy! Hope you enjoy it if it’s your thing!

Part One

Part Two

Part Three (FIN)

What are people saying about this fic?

There are no reviews yet. Be the first one to write one.

Want to leave your own review?

3 responses to “First Masterlist”

First | Part One

2nd December 2022

[…] First Masterlist […]

Reply
First | Part Two

6th January 2023

[…] First Masterlist […]

Reply
First | Part Three (FIN)

3rd February 2023

[…] First Masterlist […]

Reply

Recently Posted…

Don’t Wake Me Up || Chapter Thirteen

Dean and Y/N Winchester are finally happy and settled, living the suburban life they’d always dreamed of. But when Sam unexpectedly shows up and crashes their dream, it soon turns into a nightmare. Read more

4th April 2026
Don’t Wake Me Up || Chapter Twelve

Dean and Y/N Winchester are finally happy and settled, living the suburban life they’d always dreamed of. But when Sam unexpectedly shows up and crashes their dream, it soon turns into a nightmare. Read more

30th March 2026
Don’t Wake Me Up || Chapter Eleven

Dean and Y/N Winchester are finally happy and settled, living the suburban life they’d always dreamed of. But when Sam unexpectedly shows up and crashes their dream, it soon turns into a nightmare. Read more

21st March 2026