Summary: Cindy-Jo is John’s Omega, but secretly, she’s always wanted to belong to his sons too.

Rating: 18+ (Lots of smut, some angst, some fluff)

Tags/Warnings: Alpha!John, Alpha!Dean, Alpha!Sam, Omega!Cindy-Jo, smut from the offset, heats, p in v, ruts, claiming, cheating, multiple claiming, incest-ish but not really, daddy kink, breeding kink, polyamory, foursome, 2ps 1 v, knotting, breeding, sloppy seconds and thirds, degradation (mild)

WC: ±10K (this is the longest oneshot I’ve ever written hahaha)

A/Ns: Cindy-Jo was one of my new Third Base-ees! As she paid for her pledge annually, she decided to take most of her annual allowance for this story!

Subscribe to get access

Read this, and more content like it when you subscribe today!