Not That Girl – Cordell Walker Oneshot

Summary: You were always Emily’s best friend, the photographer of the party, and the girl he never chose.

Rating: 18+ (Smangst)

Pairing: Cordell x Reader // Cordell x Emily

Tags: angst with a capital A, sadness, flirting, drinking, teasing, fluff, pining, longing, unrequited love (ish), mild cheating, smut, p in v

A/Ns: I kinda based this fic off the song “I’m Not That Girl” from the musical Wicked, because I’ve had it stuck in my head for DAYS!! Enjoy <3

Read this, and more content like it when you subscribe today!

2 responses to “Not That Girl – Cordell Walker Oneshot”

MAJOR UPDATE – PLEASE READ

Hi everyone, Let me start by apologising. This year has been incredibly difficult for me, and my writing has slowed down a lot with weeks of my muse evading me and me being unable to write. This has meant I don’t really have much to give you, and while I am 10 chapters into a… Read more

4th May 2026
Don’t Wake Me Up || Chapter Fourteen [FIN]

Dean and Y/N Winchester are finally happy and settled, living the suburban life they’d always dreamed of. But when Sam unexpectedly shows up and crashes their dream, it soon turns into a nightmare. Read more

11th April 2026
Don’t Wake Me Up || Chapter Thirteen

Dean and Y/N Winchester are finally happy and settled, living the suburban life they’d always dreamed of. But when Sam unexpectedly shows up and crashes their dream, it soon turns into a nightmare. Read more

4th April 2026